Over the holidays I considered converting my photo catalog from Photoshop Elements Organizer to Photoshop Lightroom’s Library. There are lots of reasons to convert but the overriding item for me is how the Library and Develop pieces are more integrated than in my current work flow. On top of that Lightroom allows me more access to meta data which as time goes on will be more and more important. After I set up a test catalog in Lightroom to see how things would look I found the steps I used to catalog images in Organizer would be about the same in Lightroom. At that point the decision was made.
Now to convert. I thought it couldn’t be all that hard to convert because Lightroom has an “Import from Elements” option built right in. Software developers you can stop reading here, you know what happens next…
As with any conversion there are some things which must be done to the ‘source’ data to make it more usable in the ‘target’ system. I carefully read several posts on the preparation needed and once done I fired it off. Happily I could sit and watch as Lightroom imported my photos and tags and went about the process of organizing every thing in the Library. In a geeky way it was fun!
When the conversion finished the first thing I noticed is that some of my Organizer Tags did not land in the Lightroom keywords in the same hierarchy. As I snooped around some and I found the keywords outside the hierarchy were simply duplicated so deleting them would solve that issue. Various discussions around the Adobe Lightroom forum confirmed my conclusion. At that point I estimated 30 minutes or less to correct. So far so good.
The next thing I noticed was the captions were missing. Oh oh, that’s not good, that’s my record of train symbols and other miscellaneous facts at the time the photo was captured. Back to the forums I went looking for how to convert the captions. After hours of digging it became apparent the captions on RAW files just weren’t converting from the Organizer database to Lightroom. Lightroom’s conversion was always taking the caption from the image meta data instead of pulling it out of Organizer’s database. Some quick math told me I had just over 5,000 images with captions. To quote Aaron “That’s a lot of copy and paste”.
Lightroom is a fabulous product and it is where I want my catalog to end up. With each version it becomes more and more bug free so my hope is in one of the upcoming releases this conversion item is addressed. If its not, I will likely make the decision to convert anyway and do the copy and paste. Hey, my daughter is always wanting to earn money maybe she’d do it?
For now I’m back to Organizer.
Where’s my caption?
[tags] adobe, convert, elements, lightroom, organzier, photos, photoshop, railroad, trains [/tags]